Reid Hoffman reimagines the future of AI in 'Superagency'

Superagency explores how artificial intelligence can enhance human agency while addressing concerns about its potential risks.

Illustration by Stella Levi

By Hayu Andini and Novanka Laras

Superagency: What Could Possibly Go Right with Our AI Future, by Reid Hoffman

Buy on Amazon

Living through the emergence of transformative technology is an experience fraught with uncertainty. History has shown that groundbreaking innovations like the printing press, the telephone, and the automobile often trigger anxiety before their benefits become apparent. Concerns about threats to social norms and relationships dominated initial reactions to these advancements. Today, artificial intelligence (AI) is the latest technology stirring apprehension, fueled by dystopian narratives from 1984 to Terminator.

In his book Superagency: What Could Possibly Go Right with Our AI Future, Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn and a prominent venture capitalist, seeks to shift this narrative. Co-authored with journalist Greg Beato, Superagency challenges the widespread pessimism surrounding AI and invites readers to consider its potential to transform society for the better. Hoffman asks, “What if every child on the planet suddenly has access to an AI tutor that is as smart as Leonardo da Vinci and as empathetic as Big Bird?” He argues that instead of dwelling on fears, we should imagine the opportunities AI might create.

Hoffman positions himself as a "Bloomer" in the spectrum of AI perspectives, which he categorizes as Doomers, Gloomers, and Zoomers. Doomers view AI as an existential threat to humanity, while Gloomers, such as Shoshana Zuboff, author of The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, focus on the technology’s short-term harms like job losses and misinformation. At the opposite end are the Zoomers, represented by figures like venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, who embrace an unbridled enthusiasm for AI innovation. Hoffman’s Bloomer stance strikes a balance, advocating for optimism tempered with caution and collaborative progress.

Central to his vision is the principle of “iterative deployment,” a process that emphasizes gradual, collaborative implementation of AI technologies. Hoffman argues that this approach allows society to address emerging problems without stifling innovation with excessive regulations. He contrasts this with the “problemism” he attributes to critics outside Silicon Valley, who he says exaggerate potential dangers without acknowledging the tangible benefits technology has already delivered.

Hoffman highlights examples of AI and technology fostering trust and connection in society. Platforms like Airbnb, Uber, and LinkedIn, he claims, demonstrate how the internet has created “an unprecedented trust machine,” enabling strangers to collaborate and build relationships in ways previously unimaginable. While critics argue that big tech exploits users, Hoffman contends that platforms operate as “mutualistic ecosystems,” providing extraordinary benefits that outweigh perceived costs.

Yet, Hoffman’s arguments do not shy away from controversy. He addresses concerns about forming relationships with nonhuman entities, such as AI, by comparing them to the bonds people already form with pets, dolls, or even religious figures. While some of his analogies may provoke skepticism, they reflect his broader point: AI is not inherently dehumanizing but can enhance our connections and capabilities.

However, Superagency does grapple with the fine line between optimism and naiveté. Hoffman suggests that the global spread of U.S.-developed AI will naturally carry democratic values, but he acknowledges the need for regulations to prevent misuse by adversaries or bad actors. Critics might question whether his proposed safeguards are sufficient in the face of rapidly evolving technologies.

A recurring theme in Hoffman’s vision is human agency—the ability to make independent choices and shape one’s life. He argues that AI has the potential to amplify human agency, especially for individuals with limited skills or resources. Technologies like ChatGPT and Gemini, he believes, can democratize access to knowledge and empower users to achieve more.

However, Hoffman concedes that AI’s benefits may not be evenly distributed. A study on AI’s impact on material science research revealed that while productivity increased overall, top researchers gained the most, exacerbating inequalities. Additionally, the automation of creative tasks diminished scientists’ job satisfaction. Hoffman remains optimistic, suggesting that future generations accustomed to partnering with AI will redefine satisfaction and agency based on new achievements.

Hoffman’s advocacy for AI extends to its role in addressing societal challenges. While skeptics warn of dehumanizing surveillance and exploitation, Hoffman emphasizes technology’s capacity to celebrate individuality and foster collaboration. He acknowledges Silicon Valley’s reputation for “solutionism” but argues that its innovative mindset is vital for progress.

At its core, Superagency is an invitation to reframe our relationship with AI. Hoffman’s perspective acknowledges the technology’s risks but insists that its potential to enhance human lives outweighs the dangers. The book challenges readers to envision a future where AI amplifies human creativity, fosters equity, and addresses pressing global challenges.

Despite its hopeful tone, Superagency also underscores the complexities of realizing this vision. Hoffman’s proposals for iterative deployment and shared responsibility require global cooperation and careful oversight. His belief in AI as a democratizing force hinges on whether societies can navigate its ethical, social, and economic implications effectively.

As artificial intelligence continues to shape the world, Hoffman’s Superagency serves as a timely exploration of its possibilities and pitfalls. The book calls for a nuanced approach to AI development, one that balances innovation with accountability. For those grappling with the implications of this transformative technology, Superagency offers a compelling roadmap for navigating the challenges and opportunities ahead.

With Superagency, Reid Hoffman reframes AI not as a threat but as a tool for empowerment. Whether his vision becomes reality will depend on how societies choose to engage with this groundbreaking technology. As Hoffman writes, “What could possibly go right with our AI future?” The answer lies in our ability to embrace its potential while confronting its challenges with open minds and collaborative solutions.

Share