Sherry Thomas’ 'The One in My Heart' delivers a captivating romance

A heartfelt contemporary romance exploring love, loss, and second chances.

Illustration by Khanh Bui

By Hayu Andini and Adila Ghina

The One in My Heart, by Sherry Thomas

Sherry Thomas, widely known for her historical romances, takes a bold step into contemporary fiction with The One in My Heart. This novel, written in the first person, immerses readers in an emotional journey that lingers long after the final page. True to her signature style, Thomas delivers poetic prose that flows effortlessly, drawing readers into a world of passion, longing, and self-discovery.

Unlike her historical works, The One in My Heart introduces a modern setting with characters who grapple with the complexities of love and vulnerability. The novel opens on a stormy night, where Evangeline Canterbury, overwhelmed by sadness, finds herself crossing paths with the enigmatic and charismatic Dr. Bennett Somerset. Their connection is instantaneous, sparking a chemistry that neither can ignore.

An irresistible connection between two guarded hearts

Months after their first encounter, Evangeline meets Bennett again, only to be drawn into a scheme that forces her to confront her deepest fears. Bennett, seeking to mend ties with his estranged family, persuades Evangeline to pose as his girlfriend. Though reluctant, she finds herself unable to resist the pull of their undeniable attraction. However, Evangeline is no stranger to heartbreak—past experiences have taught her to shield herself from pain.

What unfolds is a romance that is as heartbreaking as it is beautiful. Thomas masterfully builds tension, keeping readers on edge as Evangeline and Bennett navigate their complicated relationship. The emotional stakes are high, and the inevitable moment of reckoning looms over their fragile bond.

The magic of Sherry Thomas’ storytelling

Thomas' ability to weave a compelling narrative is evident throughout The One in My Heart. While the novel starts at a slow pace, it quickly grips the reader, refusing to let go. The transition from historical to contemporary romance is seamless, showcasing Thomas’ versatility as a writer.

One of the most intriguing aspects of the novel is its first-person perspective, a departure from Thomas’ usual storytelling style. Though readers may long for insight into Bennett’s mind, his character remains vivid through Evangeline’s eyes. When he finally reveals his past, the emotional impact is profound, offering a moment of clarity that changes everything.

A hero worth falling for

Bennett Somerset is the kind of romantic hero who leaves a lasting impression. Charming, intelligent, and emotionally complex, he effortlessly captivates both Evangeline and the reader. From the moment he pushes her against the wall in a passionate embrace, it is clear that he is a force to be reckoned with. His preference for older women and belief in love at first sight only add to his allure.

Evangeline, on the other hand, is a character who embodies resilience and guarded vulnerability. She is independent, wary of love, and determined to protect herself from emotional pain. Yet, Bennett sees through her defenses, challenging her to open her heart. Their dynamic is electric, filled with moments of intense passion and emotional depth.

Beyond the central romance, The One in My Heart boasts a cast of well-developed secondary characters who enrich the story. Their presence adds layers to the narrative, making the world Thomas creates feel authentic and immersive.

The novel is also loosely connected to Private Arrangements, one of Thomas’ most emotional historical romances. This subtle tie-in adds an extra layer of intrigue for longtime fans of her work.

A deeply satisfying love story

While The One in My Heart follows a familiar romance structure, it does so with elegance and emotional intensity. Thomas avoids common pitfalls, ensuring that Evangeline’s journey feels authentic and earned. Even the presence of "the other woman" is handled with nuance, preventing the story from falling into predictable tropes.

Thomas proves once again that she has a remarkable ability to make seemingly impossible love stories work. The One in My Heart is a testament to her skill, offering a romance that is both poignant and deeply satisfying.

Sherry Thomas’ foray into contemporary romance is nothing short of spectacular. The One in My Heart is a beautifully written, emotionally charged novel that explores love, trust, and self-discovery. Fans of Thomas’ historical romances will find much to love in this new venture, while new readers will be captivated by her masterful storytelling.

With its compelling characters, heartfelt moments, and exquisite prose, The One in My Heart is a must-read for romance lovers. Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys a love story that resonates long after the final page.